The New York Times Ignores Womb Insulin Toxicity

Majid Ali, M.D.

This is an article of my series entitled “Insulin Blindness of The New York Times.” The Times regularly ignores the crucial issue of insulin toxicity in all its publications on the subjects of weight gain, obesity, prediabetes, diabetes, and diabetes complications. Why is it so? I provide examples and readers can decide for themselves if I am off the mark.

Here are crucial facts about womb insulin toxicity:

1. Excess insulin (hyperinsulinism) is toxic for pregnant women and their unborn babies.

2. Over two-thirds of adults and about one-third of children in America are overweight or obese.

3. With very uncommon exceptions, overweight or obese are insulin-toxic.

4. Obese pregnant women are much more likely to deliver large babies.

5. Babies delivered by obese pregnant women often weigh more than nine pounds.

6. Overweight newborns face a greater risk obesity and diabetes.

7. American Ob&Gyn doctors continue to ignore insulin toxicity of expecting mothers.

8. The New York Times continues to neglect the crucial issue of insulin toxicity during pregnancy.

Below is the text of an article on the subject published by The New York Times on March 29, 2015. I did a quick search of the article for any reference to insulin. I found none. I invite the reader to do a quick search and see if I did not do right.

Expecting mothers pay a huge price for neglect of their insulin toxicity by their doctors. Why doesn’t The New York Times scream about it? The answer: its advertisers do not profit from Americans finding out the truth about insulin toxicity.

Full Text of the Article of The New York Times

Pregnant, Obese … and in Danger.


BERKELEY, Calif. — ONE recent night on my delivery shift, eight out of 10 of my laboring patients were too heavy, with two weighing over 300 pounds.

Over two-thirds of adults and about one-third of children in America now are overweight or obese. An obese pregnant woman is more likely to have a very large baby, weighing roughly nine pounds or more. And babies of obese mothers are more likely to grow up to become overweight or obese themselves.

Maternal obesity causes more immediate problems as well. Obese pregnant patients are more likely to have elevated blood pressure, gestational diabetes and babies with birth complications. They are more likely to need cesareans. And they are more likely to have serious complications from the surgery, such as infections, hernias or life-threatening bleeding.

Early that night on the ward, we had a patient with a “shoulder dystocia” — a scary situation in which the baby’s head delivers, but the shoulders are too big to pass through the birth canal. Shoulder dystocia is strongly associated with obesity and excess maternal weight gain during pregnancy, and can lead to permanent fetal injury, neurological disorders and even death.

But the biggest emergency unfolded in the early morning. A 24-year-old, 300-pound diabetic woman, who was pregnant with her first child, had developed pre-eclampsia. Pre-eclampsia is a complication of pregnancy marked by elevated blood pressure, swelling and mild to severe organ dysfunction. If untreated, it can lead to the mother’s having seizures, stroke and liver rupture, and is a leading cause of maternal death. Although pre-eclampsia can occur in any pregnancy, it is three times more likely in obese patients. New research suggests that babies born to women with pre-eclampsia may have a significantly higher chance of autism or developmental delay. The only treatment for it is to deliver the baby, so this patient had been given drugs to induce her labor.

At 5 a.m. I was urgently called to her bedside. She was having seizures from the swelling and elevated blood pressures. Her baby’s heart rate dropped from 100 beats per minute to 70 to 40, and then the signal was lost — the monitor had come off.

As we worked to treat her seizure, we moved her to the operating room. We needed to sedate her, but struggled to find a vein. We needed to intubate her, but her airway was obstructed from the obesity and the swelling. Just moving her onto the operating table required an additional team: the table was too narrow and the straps too small.

Once she was safely secured to the table and intubated, I checked for the baby’s heartbeat. There was nothing on the monitors. Nor could I see the heart with the ultrasound, as the mother’s abdominal wall was too thick and swollen. There was nothing I could do but deliver the baby surgically and hope that it would survive. Quickly, I cut straight through her swollen abdomen and uterus. I reached through her placenta, wrapped my hand around the baby’s head and pulled it firmly out of the incision. As I gently extracted his body and untangled his legs from his pulsating cord, he clenched his fists and gasped.

Continue reading the main storyContinue reading the main storyContinue reading the main story

Later that morning, when I left to go home, I was deeply grateful that all my patients and their babies were safe. There were many close calls.

Obesity is a sensitive subject, even for doctors. In a JAMA study from 2011, only 45 percent of patients with a body mass index of 25 or greater (defined as overweight) and 66 percent of patients with a B.M.I. of 30 or greater (defined as obese) reported having been told by a doctor that they were overweight. Notably, those who were told were more likely to have tried to lose weight.


jp 8 days ago

When I was pregnant with my first child forty years ago, the doctor told me I could gain 20 pounds. (I was a thin 120 pounds) When I…

rac 8 days ago

It really is Emperor’s New Clothes time. We need to pussy foot around the fact that obesity is bad and unhealthy, but why? Is it a religious…

MB 8 days ago

Healthcare practitioners also need to be better models. We patients are not the only ones struggling with weight and food issues. It is hard…


There are many reasons doctors don’t speak up, including short office visits and a lack of training. But one growing problem is the role of “patient satisfaction scores,” which can be tied to doctors’ compensation and job security. If you offend a patient, you may never see her again.

But these conversations are crucial, especially for women who are, or want to become, pregnant. Obesity in mothers is strongly linked to their own compromised health, and to that of their unborn babies and our nation at large.

For doctors, the issue has become an everyday challenge. In the last year alone, three of the doctors I work with have been significantly injured while treating severely obese women. One even dislocated his shoulder while performing a cesarean on a 400-pound patient. We recently had two patients with B.M.I.’s of 53 and 60 in labor at the same time. B.M.I.’s above 50 are now classified in a new category: “super-obese.” It is frightening to think that this might become normal.

Policy makers need to pay attention. We should consider creating special labor and delivery centers for severely obese patients that are equipped with automatic lifts, specially designed monitors and appropriately trained teams.

We also need better prenatal programs that assist women in achieving appropriate weight goals during pregnancy, through better exercise and nutrition. The adage of “eating for two” is damaging. Thankfully, under the Affordable Care Act, more women and children have access to nutrition and health services than ever before. But we should be managing obesity even more aggressively, as we do elevated blood pressure and diabetes.

Above all, we need to end the taboo against talking frankly about obesity. Doctors need to be sensitive and nonjudgmental, and patients should not take offense, especially when their health, and their children’s health, is at stake.

Claire A. Putnam is an obstetrician and gynecologist at a Kaiser Permanente hospital.

Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook and Twitter.

A version of this op-ed appears in print on March 29, 2015, on page SR10 of the New

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s